Perguntas Tamanho da borboleta - Vamos discutir a melhor configuração?
Tamanho da borboleta - Vamos discutir a melhor configuração?
07/02/2010 às 16:52
Fala pessoal do Hot Campinas !!! Blz ??
Estou abrindo este tópico com o intuito de discutirmos esse assunto que é bastante contraditório e polêmico. Borboleta grande ou pequena ?? Qual a melhor configuração para rendimento, borboleta grande ou pequena no coletor MI ou coletor EFI e borboleta dupla.
Sei que várias pessoas vão opinar pelo coletor EFI + borboleta dupla pela progressividade, mas hoje temos recursos de booster controler e ccontrole de tração que auxiliam a colocar o carro mais no chão e matar um pouco da agressividade da borboleta grande.
Esta dúvida se refere a dois carros que estao sendo montados para turbo B, sendo que um utiliza cabeçote unilateral e outro fluxo cruzado.
Segue a copia de um tópico do VW Vortex que fala sobre um teste com motor 1.8 20v turbo alterando o tamanho da borboleta
Onto the show:
Quote, originally posted by Unitronic 1.8T Engine Spec »
* Stock AWP "Small port" 1.8T Engine
* Panchi 144/19mm drop in connecting rods
* SEM Motorsport small port intake manifold + 80 x 80 throttle body plate
* Custom tubular v-band manifold
* GT3071R w/ TiAL v-band 0.63 A/R turbine housing
* TiAL 38mm MVS wastegate
* Unitronic Chipped BT 18deg file
All throttle bodies were tested doing 2 pulls at 1 bar and 1.5 bar respectively. 1 bar being wastegate pressure of 14.7psi (was actually 17psi due to the SEM manifold) and 1.5bar being controlled with a greddy unit (22psi).Below is a recording of peak power made in each dyno run using the SEM small port manifold & the respective throttle body. For reference we have included what the same engine made utilizing a stock AWP manifold and throttle body.
For this test the following nomenclature represents each throttle body.
80mm = Dodge Hemi 5.7L
75mm = Audi B5 RS4 2.7L - TT
70mm = Mercedes-Benz C320 – 3.2L
65mm = Audi B5 S4 – 2.7L / VW Golf & Jetta 2.8 24V VR6
60mm = Volkswagen Passat B5 1.8T
Cross Section Area's of the throttle plates / Percentage increase % over stock 60mm unit
80mm = 5026 mm2 / +77.7%
75mm = 4417 mm2 / +56.3%
70mm = 3848 mm2 / +36.1%
65mm = 3318 mm2 / +17.4%
60mm = 2827 mm2 / +0%
TESTS:
HORSEPOWER / correctedhp
BOOST : Wastegate pressure - 17PSI
80mm: = 388.9 hp @ 7300 rpm
75mm: = 390 hp @ ?
70mm: = 383 hp @ 7200 rpm
65mm: = 378 hp @ 6500 rpm
60mm: = 374 hp @ 6700 rpm
BOOST - 22SI
80mm: = 451 @ 6700 rpm
75mm: = 447 hp @ ?
70mm: = 447 hp @ 6700 rpm
65mm: = 430 hp @ 6800 rpm
60mm: = 439 hp @ 6800 rpm
STOCK AWP Manifold + 60mm: = 421 hp @ 7100 rpm
TORQUE / lb-ft
BOOST : Wastegate pressure - 17PSI
80mm: = 322 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
75mm: = 333 lb-ft @ ?
70mm: = 318 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
65mm: = 320 lb-ft @ 5800 rpm
60mm: = 312 lb-ft @ 5700 rpm
BOOST - 22SI
80mm: = 380 lb-ft @ 5500 rpm
75mm: = 382 lb-ft @ ?
70mm: = 374 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
65mm: = 369 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
60mm: = 371 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
STOCK AWP Manifold + 60mm: = 365 lb-ft @ 5100 rpm
NOTES:
80mm:
As expected on the 80mm unit, the most power was developed, great throttle body for an all out drag car.
75mm:
RS4 throttle body results were very surprising, the 75mm unit made more power at WG pressure, had better idle and better response than the 80mm unit.
70mm:
This unit relieved the chope point noted in smaller throttle bodies.
Power gains were also noted above wastegate pressure noted.
65mm:
Also we noted that a choke point was created at 7000 rpm's. Engine response became sluggish and timing was pulled to compensate for choke point created due to too small a throttle plate.
60mm:
This is the throttle body that I believe a lot of big turbo users need to keep an eye on. What could be timing being pulled due to a "bad tune" could be associated with too small a throttle body. At 6900 rpm's it was literally like hitting a brick wall. Engine started to choke and detonation was being detected.
CONCLUSIONS:
1. If you are running a turbocharger rated for 450hp or more , then it is highly recommended to have a throttle body greater than 65mm.We expected the results to be amplified had the motor been built with a larger ported cylinder head (AEB/AJL/ADR).
2. For 99.99% of the 1.8T users, a 70mm / 75mm DBW throttle body will more than suite your needs.
3. If you are a user with a home brew or custom intake manifold with a larger plenum and you are running a stock 60mm throttle body then you are actually hurting performance rather than helping and it is recommended you get an upgrade. Same applies for users running an SEM motorsport intake manifold and a 60mm OEM throttle body.
4. Throttle body adaptations can only get you so far. Every single one of these throttle bodies needed the map to be tweaked. In no situation was it a simple "plug and go" . Some might get away with lemiwinks whereas others will have to look into an entire motronic retune.
Fonte: VW Vortex
Agradeço a quem puder contribuir com comentários e experiências práticas.
Abraço a todos
Estou abrindo este tópico com o intuito de discutirmos esse assunto que é bastante contraditório e polêmico. Borboleta grande ou pequena ?? Qual a melhor configuração para rendimento, borboleta grande ou pequena no coletor MI ou coletor EFI e borboleta dupla.
Sei que várias pessoas vão opinar pelo coletor EFI + borboleta dupla pela progressividade, mas hoje temos recursos de booster controler e ccontrole de tração que auxiliam a colocar o carro mais no chão e matar um pouco da agressividade da borboleta grande.
Esta dúvida se refere a dois carros que estao sendo montados para turbo B, sendo que um utiliza cabeçote unilateral e outro fluxo cruzado.
Segue a copia de um tópico do VW Vortex que fala sobre um teste com motor 1.8 20v turbo alterando o tamanho da borboleta
Onto the show:
Quote, originally posted by Unitronic 1.8T Engine Spec »
* Stock AWP "Small port" 1.8T Engine
* Panchi 144/19mm drop in connecting rods
* SEM Motorsport small port intake manifold + 80 x 80 throttle body plate
* Custom tubular v-band manifold
* GT3071R w/ TiAL v-band 0.63 A/R turbine housing
* TiAL 38mm MVS wastegate
* Unitronic Chipped BT 18deg file
All throttle bodies were tested doing 2 pulls at 1 bar and 1.5 bar respectively. 1 bar being wastegate pressure of 14.7psi (was actually 17psi due to the SEM manifold) and 1.5bar being controlled with a greddy unit (22psi).Below is a recording of peak power made in each dyno run using the SEM small port manifold & the respective throttle body. For reference we have included what the same engine made utilizing a stock AWP manifold and throttle body.
For this test the following nomenclature represents each throttle body.
80mm = Dodge Hemi 5.7L
75mm = Audi B5 RS4 2.7L - TT
70mm = Mercedes-Benz C320 – 3.2L
65mm = Audi B5 S4 – 2.7L / VW Golf & Jetta 2.8 24V VR6
60mm = Volkswagen Passat B5 1.8T
Cross Section Area's of the throttle plates / Percentage increase % over stock 60mm unit
80mm = 5026 mm2 / +77.7%
75mm = 4417 mm2 / +56.3%
70mm = 3848 mm2 / +36.1%
65mm = 3318 mm2 / +17.4%
60mm = 2827 mm2 / +0%
TESTS:
HORSEPOWER / correctedhp
BOOST : Wastegate pressure - 17PSI
80mm: = 388.9 hp @ 7300 rpm
75mm: = 390 hp @ ?
70mm: = 383 hp @ 7200 rpm
65mm: = 378 hp @ 6500 rpm
60mm: = 374 hp @ 6700 rpm
BOOST - 22SI
80mm: = 451 @ 6700 rpm
75mm: = 447 hp @ ?
70mm: = 447 hp @ 6700 rpm
65mm: = 430 hp @ 6800 rpm
60mm: = 439 hp @ 6800 rpm
STOCK AWP Manifold + 60mm: = 421 hp @ 7100 rpm
TORQUE / lb-ft
BOOST : Wastegate pressure - 17PSI
80mm: = 322 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
75mm: = 333 lb-ft @ ?
70mm: = 318 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
65mm: = 320 lb-ft @ 5800 rpm
60mm: = 312 lb-ft @ 5700 rpm
BOOST - 22SI
80mm: = 380 lb-ft @ 5500 rpm
75mm: = 382 lb-ft @ ?
70mm: = 374 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
65mm: = 369 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
60mm: = 371 lb-ft @ 5600 rpm
STOCK AWP Manifold + 60mm: = 365 lb-ft @ 5100 rpm
NOTES:
80mm:
As expected on the 80mm unit, the most power was developed, great throttle body for an all out drag car.
75mm:
RS4 throttle body results were very surprising, the 75mm unit made more power at WG pressure, had better idle and better response than the 80mm unit.
70mm:
This unit relieved the chope point noted in smaller throttle bodies.
Power gains were also noted above wastegate pressure noted.
65mm:
Also we noted that a choke point was created at 7000 rpm's. Engine response became sluggish and timing was pulled to compensate for choke point created due to too small a throttle plate.
60mm:
This is the throttle body that I believe a lot of big turbo users need to keep an eye on. What could be timing being pulled due to a "bad tune" could be associated with too small a throttle body. At 6900 rpm's it was literally like hitting a brick wall. Engine started to choke and detonation was being detected.
CONCLUSIONS:
1. If you are running a turbocharger rated for 450hp or more , then it is highly recommended to have a throttle body greater than 65mm.We expected the results to be amplified had the motor been built with a larger ported cylinder head (AEB/AJL/ADR).
2. For 99.99% of the 1.8T users, a 70mm / 75mm DBW throttle body will more than suite your needs.
3. If you are a user with a home brew or custom intake manifold with a larger plenum and you are running a stock 60mm throttle body then you are actually hurting performance rather than helping and it is recommended you get an upgrade. Same applies for users running an SEM motorsport intake manifold and a 60mm OEM throttle body.
4. Throttle body adaptations can only get you so far. Every single one of these throttle bodies needed the map to be tweaked. In no situation was it a simple "plug and go" . Some might get away with lemiwinks whereas others will have to look into an entire motronic retune.
Fonte: VW Vortex
Agradeço a quem puder contribuir com comentários e experiências práticas.
Abraço a todos
Por favor Entrar ou Registrar para participar da conversa.
Re: Tamanho da borboleta - Vamos discutir a melhor configuração?
08/02/2010 às 23:57
vai do seu cabeçote e do seu coletor.. se é plenum ou se eh normal... só testando em banca de fluxo pra chegar a melhor configuraçao pra cada cabeçote.. cada caso é um caso... abraço!
EU DIGO NÃO PARA O NITROMETANO NA ARRANCADA!
Turbo é moda! Aspirado é foda! 2100 + troyano heads+prt 46mm = D.O. 83 TERUO MOTORSPORT!
Turbo é moda! Aspirado é foda! 2100 + troyano heads+prt 46mm = D.O. 83 TERUO MOTORSPORT!
Por favor Entrar ou Registrar para participar da conversa.